Williams Candy Shop at 1318 Surf Avenue, Brooklyn, New York.

This is the ONLY place at Coney Island to buy caramel apples. I've been going here my whole life and the few times my family has tried other places closer to the boardwalk we've been really disappointed. So we've learned to get the apples first thing outside the subway! Their quality hasn't gone down in three decades. Just bought two today and they're as delicious as ever! Figured it's worth a review after all these years.